قَالَ يَٰبُنَىَّ لَا تَقْصُصْ رُءْيَاكَ عَلَىٰٓ إِخْوَتِكَ فَيَكِيدُوا۟ لَكَ كَيْدًا إِنَّ ٱلشَّيْطَٰنَ لِلْإِنسَٰنِ عَدُوٌّ مُّبِينٌ

“He said: O my dear son! Tell not thy brethren of thy vision, lest they plot a plot against thee. Lo! Satan is for man an open foe.” — M. M. Pickthall

Tafsirs

AI-generated
Taberî9-10. c.✓ Citation verified

According to Taberî, when Jacob told Joseph not to tell his dream to his brothers, he indicated that if he did tell them, his brothers would become jealous of him, set traps for him, and harbor enmity toward him, and in this way they would obey Satan. Jacob made this warning based on having previously noticed signs of jealousy directed at Joseph from among his brothers.

نزل يعقوب الشام، فكان همه يوسف وأخاه، فحسده إخوته لما رأوا حب أبيه له، ورأى يوسف في المنام كأن أحد عشر كوكبا والشمس والقمر رآهم له ساجدين، فحدث بها أباه
Kurtubî13. c.✓ Citation verified

Kurtubî explains the warning regarding the brothers being able to plot against Joseph ('يحتالوا في هلاكك'), and then emphasizes that the dream is an honorable state and a high station, listing various hadith narrations (from sections 46, 70, 40, 49, 50, 26, 44) regarding the fact that the dream is a portion of prophethood. He clarifies that these different numbers do not contradict one another, explaining that the proximity of one's dream to prophethood changes according to the degree of one's piety, sincerity, and certainty; the dream of a truthful and God-fearing person is closer to prophethood (40 parts), while the dream of a person of moderate status corresponds to a degree between 40-70 parts.

فمن كان من أهل إسباغ الوضوء في السبرات والصبر في الله على المكروهات وانتظار الصلاة بعد الصلاة فرؤياه الصالحة إن شاء الله جزء من أربعين جزءا من النبوة ومن كانت حاله في ذاته بين ذلك فرؤياه الصادقة بين جزأين ما بين الأربعين إلى الستين لا تنقص عن سبعين وتزيد على الأربعين
İbn Kesîr14. c.✓ Citation verified

Ibn Kesîr explains Jacob's advice to Joseph not to tell his brothers about his dream as stemming from fear that his brothers would set traps for him. He supports this view with hadith narrations stating that unpleasant things seen in dreams should not be told to others and that dreams do not come to pass unless they are interpreted, and he also mentions the narration regarding the necessity of concealing blessings as evidence for this context.

أي يحتالوا لك حيلة يردونك فيها ولهذا ثبتت السنة عن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم قال إذا رأى أحدكم ما يحب فليحدث به وإذا رأى ما يكره فليتحول إلى جنبه الآخر وليتفل عن يساره ثلاثا وليستعذ بالله من شرها ولا يحدث بها أحدا فانها لن تضره
Beydâvî13. c.✓ Citation verified

According to Beydâvî, Jacob told his son Joseph not to tell his brothers about his dream; because, as the dream indicated, he sensed that God would choose Joseph and make him superior to his brothers, and for this reason he feared their jealousy and injustice. Furthermore, he enters into a linguistic and rational/philosophical analysis by explaining the difference between dream (رؤيا) and sight (رؤية), stating that the imagined vision occurring in sleep is an imprint formed through the relationship between the soul and the realm of the unseen. Finally, he states that Satan is an open enemy to mankind, and just as he did to Adam and Eve, he will try to incite the brothers and provoke jealousy in them to make them set traps for Joseph.

فهم يعقوب عليه السلام من رؤياه أن الله يصطفيه لرسالته ويفوقه على إخوته، فخاف عليه حسدهم وبغيهم
Fahreddin er-Râzî12-13. c.✓ Citation verified

According to this exegete, the verb 'kaydûke' is in the accusative case with the proviso 'an', and the meaning is 'if you tell them this, they will set traps for you.' Since the brothers' attempt at this plot is attributed to Satan, Jacob's counsel was referring to the interpretation of the dream.

والمعنى إن قصصتها عليهم كادوك

Comparison

Common ground

All exegetes agree that Jacob's warning to Joseph not to tell his brothers about his dream is based on the fear that his brothers would become jealous and set traps for him, and that this plot is connected to Satan's incitement.

Differences

While Taberî relies on narrations and syntactic analysis based on the narration of al-Suddî, Kurtubî elaborates on the relationship between the dream and prophethood with hadith narrations and uses a method of reconciling different narrations. Ibn Kesîr is hadith-focused and adds the theme of concealing blessings, Beydâvî, in addition to linguistic analysis, treats the difference between dream and sight within a philosophical/soul-realm of unseen framework, while al-Râzî focuses solely on a linguistic analysis.

Historical context

Early-period exegetes (Taberî, Ibn Kesîr) were content with narration and hadith-based explanations, whereas later exegetes (Kurtubî, Beydâvî, al-Râzî) enriched the interpretation by bringing in linguistic/rhetorical analysis and in part rational-philosophical elements; the fundamental meaning (fear of jealousy and plotting) has remained constant.

Modern connection

This narrative points to how jealousy within family relationships can produce negative outcomes and to the importance of an elder using cautious words to anticipate and try to soften such tensions beforehand. The principle of not openly discussing blessings and successes to everyone can still offer a thought-provoking measure today regarding preserving social harmony and not triggering feelings such as malice.

AI analysis — not a fatwa or ruling, not yet reviewed by a scholar